When news first broke that It Ends With Us, Colleen Hoover’s bestselling novel, was being adapted into a film, I was thrilled. I’d devoured the book, captivated by its powerful portrayal of love, resilience, and the complex nature of abuse. But as soon as Blake Lively was announced as the lead, Lily Bloom, my excitement shifted to curiosity—and for many fans, disappointment.
Don’t get me wrong, I love Blake Lively. From Gossip Girl to A Simple Favor, she’s proven her talent, and her charm is undeniable. But as soon as her casting was revealed, social media was ablaze with mixed reactions. Why were fans so critical? And what does this controversy say about the complicated relationship between book fans and movie adaptations?
The Book That Sparked It All
First, a bit of backstory on It Ends With Us. Colleen Hoover’s novel dives into a deeply personal and emotional story of Lily Bloom, a woman navigating the complexities of love, dating, domestic violence, and self-discovery. Inspired by Hoover’s own experiences, the book is a raw, unflinching look at the cycle of abuse and the strength it takes to break free.
For many readers, It Ends With Us was more than just a love story. It was a cathartic, relatable experience. It resonated with people who had been through similar struggles or who wanted to understand the complexities of abusive relationships. Lily’s journey wasn’t about simple romance or fairytale endings—it was about hard choices and finding strength.
So, when it came time to cast the film, fans were understandably protective of the characters they felt connected to so deeply, especially our beloved heroine, Lily.
Blake Lively as Lily: A Controversial Choice
When Blake Lively was cast as Lily, social media erupted with mixed reactions. Many fans voiced concerns that Lively, despite her talent and charisma, might not align with the Lily they’d imagined. Now that the film is out, those initial worries seem to have been both validated and challenged, depending on who you ask.
Lively’s portrayal of Lily Bloom in It Ends With Us has sparked a wide range of reactions from fans and critics. Many praised her for bringing emotional depth and maturity to Lily’s journey, with standout moments capturing the raw vulnerability and resilience of a woman breaking free from an abusive relationship. Critics highlighted her layered performance, noting how her portrayal added gravitas to the role, even surprising skeptics who initially doubted her casting. For some fans, Lively’s maturity enhanced Lily’s strength, making her growth feel more impactful.
Some viewers felt Blake Lively’s version of Lily was different from the youthful, down-to-earth character in the book. Her polished and glamorous look didn’t match the relatable image many fans had imagined, and her age made Lily’s naivety and early struggles feel less authentic. Despite this, Lively’s performance left a strong impression, with many agreeing that she captured Lily’s pain and strength, even if she wasn’t exactly how fans pictured her.
The Importance of Authenticity
One thing this controversy highlights is how much representation and authenticity matter to audiences. When we read a book and connect with a character, we build an image in our minds that feels true to that story. Casting someone who doesn’t align with that image can feel like a betrayal, or at least a compromise.
I’ll admit, when I first heard the news, I had mixed feelings too. Part of me felt protective of the story, wanting it to be as authentic as possible. I wanted to see a Lily who reflected the journey I’d read about, who looked and felt like someone who’d gone through her unique struggles. And let’s face it—Blake Lively’s Hollywood image didn’t quite match that picture in my mind.
But this conversation goes beyond just casting. It speaks to the need for movie adaptations to honor the essence of the story and respect the emotional investment of fans. After all, books like It Ends With Us don’t just have readers—they have devoted communities of fans who feel deeply connected to the story.
How the Film Interpreted the Story
The film stayed largely faithful to the book, capturing the emotional highs and lows of Lily’s journey. Scenes depicting her relationship with Ryle and her complicated bond with Atlas were handled with care, maintaining the tension and heartbreak that made the novel so impactful.
However, some fans felt the adaptation softened the edges of the story, particularly when it came to the depiction of abuse. While the book is unflinching in its portrayal, the film opted for a slightly more restrained approach. For some, this made the story more accessible to a wider audience. For others, it felt like a compromise that dulled the emotional impact.
The Supporting Cast and Chemistry
While Blake Lively’s portrayal of Lily Bloom was the centerpiece of It Ends With Us, the supporting cast brought their own layers of complexity and intrigue to the story. Justin Baldoni’s performance as Ryle was particularly polarizing, as he balanced the character’s outward charm with his darker, abusive tendencies. Baldoni’s portrayal effectively captured the emotional rollercoaster of Ryle’s duality, making him both charismatic and deeply unsettling.
In scenes where Ryle’s temper flared, Baldoni’s intense emotional range left audiences grappling with the complexity of loving someone who is ultimately harmful. Critics noted that Baldoni’s ability to show flashes of vulnerability made Ryle feel tragically human, even as his actions became increasingly unforgivable.
Brandon Sklenar’s portrayal of Atlas, in contrast, was a calming and steadfast presence. As Lily’s childhood love and emotional anchor, Sklenar’s performance gave audiences a sense of hope amidst the chaos of Lily’s life. His understated delivery and quiet strength made Atlas a fan favorite, with many praising the tenderness he brought to key moments.
However, some viewers felt Atlas’s story wasn’t explored as deeply as it could have been, leaving his relationship with Lily slightly underdeveloped compared to the intensity of her dynamic with Ryle. Fans of the book expressed a wish for more screen time to flesh out Atlas’s backstory and his deep emotional connection with Lily.
The chemistry between the leads sparked significant conversation among fans. Lively and Baldoni’s dynamic was electrifying in their most dramatic scenes, with palpable tension and raw emotion fueling their on-screen fights and reconciliations. Conversely, the bond between Lively and Sklenar was described as heartfelt but understated, with their moments together exuding quiet intimacy. While some fans appreciated the gentle nature of their interactions, others hoped for more passion and depth to better convey the life-altering impact Atlas has on Lily’s journey.
Moving Forward: What the Film Means for Fans
The release of It Ends With Us has reignited debates about book-to-film adaptations and the delicate balance between staying true to the source material and creating something new. For many fans, the film was an emotional experience that brought their favorite story to life in a way they’d been longing for. For others, it was a bittersweet reminder of how difficult it is to translate a deeply personal book into a mainstream movie.
Personally, I found myself both moved and frustrated. Blake Lively’s Lily wasn’t the Lily I’d envisioned, but she brought something unexpected to the role—a maturity and depth that added a new layer to the story. While the film didn’t perfectly capture the rawness of the book, it still managed to convey its heart: the strength it takes to break free from the cycle of abuse and choose a better path.
Other Fun Facts About It Ends With Us
- Blake Lively brought her personal touch to Lily’s wardrobe by working closely with costume designers. Some pieces were pulled directly from her own closet to reflect Lily’s evolution.
- Colleen Hoover makes a cameo in the florist shop scene as a customer purchasing an unusual bouquet, a delightful Easter egg for fans of her work.
- The set for Lily Bloom’s floral shop was designed based on Colleen Hoover’s original vision. Many floral arrangements were crafted to match descriptions from the novel.
- Blake Lively was aware of the fan backlash regarding her casting and used it as motivation to embody Lily fully. Her performance aimed to challenge fans’ initial doubts.
- Several Easter eggs for book fans are scattered throughout the film, including Lily’s diary, which features a doodle of the “naked truth” logo from the book.
- Justin Baldoni, who plays Ryle, nearly turned down the role due to its complexity. After consulting with domestic violence advocates, he embraced the challenge of portraying such a layered character.
- During early table reads, the cast was moved to tears multiple times. Blake Lively shared that the scene where Lily breaks free from Ryle left even the crew emotional.
- The journals Lily writes in were handwritten by the props team, complete with doodles, notes, and corrections. Blake Lively kept one of these as a keepsake.
- The scene where Atlas cooks for Lily features real recipes provided by Colleen Hoover. The lasagna seen on screen is based on one of Hoover’s family recipes.
- The floral arrangements in Lily Bloom’s shop were carefully selected for their symbolism, with lilies representing purity and rebirth, echoing Lily’s personal journey.
- Fan input influenced the film’s direction. The rooftop kiss between Lily and Atlas, played by Brandon Sklenar, was expanded to honor its status as a beloved moment in the book.
- Some of the film’s most emotional moments were improvised. Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni added unscripted dialogue to deepen the intensity of key scenes.
- Lily’s floral shop includes a “naked truth” wall where customers pin personal truths. This addition wasn’t in the script but was added as a tribute to the book’s readers.
- Blake Lively learned floral arranging to authentically portray Lily. She enjoyed the process so much that she made bouquets for the cast and crew during filming breaks.
- After the trailer’s release, sales of It Ends With Us surged, bringing the book back to bestseller lists long after its initial release.
- The chemistry between Blake Lively and Brandon Sklenar (Atlas) was described as “electric” during auditions, and their dynamic shines on screen, thrilling Team Atlas fans.
- Justin Baldoni worked with a psychologist to accurately portray Ryle, ensuring his character’s charm and abusive tendencies were authentically balanced.
- The film’s closing scene hints at It Starts With Us, leaving fans speculating about a potential sequel and what’s next for Lily and Atlas.
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, It Ends With Us was never going to please everyone. The novel’s devoted fanbase ensured that expectations were sky-high, and no adaptation could ever fully match the personal connection readers have to the story. But the film succeeded in sparking conversations, eliciting strong emotions, and bringing Lily’s journey to a new audience.
Whether you loved or disliked the adaptation, one thing is clear: It Ends With Us continues to resonate, proving the enduring power of Colleen Hoover’s story. And while the film may not be perfect, it’s a testament to the impact of a book that continues to inspire and challenge us to think about love, resilience, and the choices that define us.
Also Read:
